Your TR Source

Taxation

Chronology January 1892 to December 1898

Chronology January 1892 to December 1898

Chronology of the daily life of Theodore Roosevelt from January 1892 to December 1898. Notable events include the death of Elliott Roosevelt, Theodore Roosevelt is appointed New York City Police Commissioner, his tenure as Assistant Secretary of the Navy, the Spanish-American War, and Roosevelt’s gubernatorial campaign.

Collection

Theodore Roosevelt Association

Creation Date

1985

Hearings before the Committee on Interstate Commerce

Hearings before the Committee on Interstate Commerce

Part four of Hearings before the committee on interstate commerce starts part way through a hearing in which Mr. Martin answers questions from the senators regarding the dissolution of trusts and the consequences to stockholders. A statement of Andrew Jaritz begins on page 174 in which Jaritz presents his ideas and conclusions on the permanent and progressive habits of economic legislation and the need for economic principles. Jaritz suggests the government frame trusts within the context of the economy and work for the people to set reasonable prices and prevent waste by the producers and the consumers. The government could then profit from the savings and continue regulating and enforcing economic legislation by forming a new department of economic policy.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1911-11-17

The Corporation Tax

The Corporation Tax

Robert Montgomery addresses the Editor of the Daily Ledger on the topic of taxation of corporations, responding specifically to a recent statement by John Bigelow proposing the establishment of “a law which will make the government a junior partner and small profit-sharer in corporations which operate under a charter granting remunerative privileges.” Montgomery judges this idea as a reasonable one, and highlights as the basis of the recently enacted corporation tax. This law is under review by the Supreme Court, and Montgomery does his best to explain and defend the legal basis of the law.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1911-03-05

Specials today

Specials today

President Roosevelt holds a sack and has a sign tied around his neck, “Specials today: Inheritance Tax, Income Tax, Federal Control of Mineral Lands.” In the foreground a Teddy bear rips out pages of a “Democratic Recipe Book” while William Jennings Bryan says, “I always said he was a Democrat.” The cow beside Bryan says, “My book!”

comments and context

Comments and Context

The Evening Star, consistently a Republican-leaning newspaper through its history (which mostly was in control of the Noyes family) made noise when it thought the party strayed from orthodoxy. Such was the case with this Clifford Kennedy Berryman cartoon of 1907, when many politicians and commentators noticed that President Roosevelt was adopting, or publicly considering, some radical policies.

See if you can hit the apple, Mr. Roosevelt

See if you can hit the apple, Mr. Roosevelt

President Roosevelt holds a bow with an arrow labeled “Tariff Revision” and two other arrows in his mouth, “Income Tax” and “Inheritance Tax.” Just beyond him is a man labeled “Trusts” with a large apple labeled “The Tariff” on his head. The man has the arrows, “Anti-rebate,” “Anti-trust” “Railroad Rate Law,” and “Pure Food” in his chest, and he is saying, “The most unkindest cut of all!” Caption: “See if you can hit the apple, Mr. Roosevelt.”

Comments and Context

Both President Roosevelt and Secretary of State Elihu Root went public with ideas about economic and governmental reforms that shocked many people in the Republican Party and on Wall Street. Chief among these were theoretical considerations of a national income tax and a national inheritance tax. These concepts previously had been relegated, and rejected, by many Americans as Populist or even Socialist dogma.

The year 1906 had been one of tremendous ferment in politics and the economy — laws, regulations, Muckraking agitation, arrest of corporate leaders, elections of reformers. Roosevelt inspired some of these movements; he was pressured by some of them; and he did have a fear of revolution if mild reforms did not anticipate unrest. As he included some of these ideas in Annual Message in December, he made sure that Root, who agreed with the thrust of these reforms, went public too — thus removing some of the sting felt by conservative Republicans and financiers.

Mr. Asquith Prime Minister

Mr. Asquith Prime Minister

The article discusses H. H. Asquith’s ascension to the role of Prime Minister, and makes note of the fact that his appointment by King Edward VII took place in Biarritz, France. The article also discusses the political and economic conditions that Asquith and his government will face, particularly focusing on tariffs and taxation.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1908-04-09

Under control

Under control

A fire at the Treasury Building is billowing clouds of smoke labeled “Deficit.” Nelson W. Aldrich is the fire chief, and he is telling firefighters Stephen B. Elkins, Joseph Gurney Cannon, Sereno Elisha Payne, and Jacob H. Gallinger to send a fire engine labeled “Lower Tariff” back to the station. President William H. Taft and Elihu Root carry a large fire extinguisher labeled “Corporation Tax” and race up the steps of the building, attempting to extinguish the blaze. Caption: Chief Aldrich (at the great Treasury blaze) — Send that engine home! We’ll put her out with the extinguisher!

Comments and Context

Udo J. Keppler’s cartoon, for all its drama while debates over tariff legislation were raging in the Capital, betrays a certain ambiguity. Editorially, Puck frequently through the years occasionally was ambiguous about its position on tariffs and trusts. So were the political parties, despite the Republicans (who received the cartoonist’s attention here) generally being the party of big business and high tariffs. President Roosevelt had begun to warm to the concept of “fair trade” and reciprocal trade agreements, on a country-to-country basis. Such concepts would be strongly advocated by President William H. Taft, particularly with the Philippines; and famously with Canada. He was to stake — and lose — much of his political capital, urging Canadian reciprocity.

The ambiguity inherent in this cartoon rests in the position of the Republican leader of the Senate, Nelson W. Aldrich, who was then shaping the tariff bill (Payne-Aldrich) under consideration. In the cartoon he rejects the use of low-tariff water to extinguish the federal deficit, and urges instead higher corporate taxes — both concepts purportedly anathemas, or at least counter-intuitive, to Republican orthodoxy.

The fountain of taxation

The fountain of taxation

A large fountain has four basins labeled from top down, “Millionaire,” “Well-to-do,” “Middle Class,” and “Laboring Class.” The fountain stands on a platform labeled “Tax System.” The water, cascading down through each basin, is labeled “Burden of Taxation.” Caption: Eventually the bottom basin gets it.

Comments and Context

The bottom basin in Udo J. Keppler’s odd cartoon without figures, features an off-putting octopus, surely keeping people from the fountain.

One can never second-guess a historical creator, but Keppler’s evident point — another class-conscious statement by the crusading artist — was the inevitable and unjust burden on the poor. One wonders if, instead of “burdens” of taxation at the bottom basin, Keppler might have called his fountain the “Benefits of Taxation” and made the smallest basin at top, forever losing its water, and the wealthy collecting most of the water at the bottom.

An old fable brought up to date

An old fable brought up to date

A “countryman” labeled “Rep. Party” carries a whip and drives a donkey labeled “Taxpayer” who is carrying a large sack labeled “War Tariff” that contains a counter weight labeled “Iniquitous Pensions” on its back. Caption: A countryman having some grain to carry to the mill, was bothered as to how to balance the load upon his donkey’s back. Finally he hit upon the expedient of placing a large stone in the other end of the sack. Thus did he balance matters to his great satisfaction; – but to the doubling of the load on the donkey.

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1893-12-13

A handicap needed

A handicap needed

A bicycle race is underway on the “National Track” with the man in the lead labeled “National Expenses” easily outstripping the second bicyclist labeled “National Revenue.” A man labeled “Dingley” is giving the second bicyclist a push. Caption: As run at present the man behind has no show.

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1898-01-12

What he wants to see, be gosh!

What he wants to see, be gosh!

Print shows a “Hayseed Legislator” standing on the sidewalk of “Fifth Ave.” in New York City, pointing his umbrella toward a tenement house labeled “The Vanderbilt Flats Formerly the Marble Palace.” On Fifth Avenue there are street urchins, a hurdy-gurdy man with a monkey, a fruit vendor, and a man picking through the trash. Seen through windows on the ground floor of the tenement house are a woman using a sewing machine and a Chinese laundry. On the rooftop, a woman is hanging clothes on a clothesline. Caption: The New York up-country legislator will never be satisfied until he has taxed the millionaire out of the state.

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1898-10-26

He never could stand prosperity

He never could stand prosperity

A “Hayseed” legislator wearing a hat labeled “N.Y. Republican Party” sits in a stupor on a large jug labeled “Raines Law,” holding a large wine bottle labeled “Hayseed Legislation.” He is slumped against a wall labeled “Albany,” with a bottle of alcohol at his feet labeled “Progressive Inheritance Tax,” and a bottle in his coat pocket labeled “Black’s Civil Service Bill.” The figure may represent Frank Swett Black, governor of New York. A man wearing a cap labeled “Tammany” is pulling papers labeled “Greater New York Patronage” from inside the coat of the legislator.

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1897-05-26

“Goodness gracious! I must have been dozing!”

“Goodness gracious! I must have been dozing!”

President Taft sits in a rocking chair, tangled in yarn from balls labeled “Conservation, Rail Road Legislation, Postal Savings Tax, Income Tax, [and] Corporation Tax” that have fallen onto the floor and are the playthings of three cats labeled “The House, Senate, [and] The Cabinet” and a dog labeled “The Courts.” One ball of yarn labeled “My Policies” remains in a box shaped like the U.S. Capitol. Theodore Roosevelt is watching, disapprovingly, from a window on the side of the room.

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1910-06-22

Congressional contempt

Congressional contempt

A “Republican” Congressman ice skates with a “Monopolist” on the “Capitol Skating Pond.” Together they hold a stick labeled “Money Interests.” Skating nearby is a man labeled “Democracy.” Between these men is another man who has fallen through the ice at a spot labeled “Needless Taxation.” His hat labeled “Tax Payer” rests on the ice. Caption: Republican Congressman – “He is howling for help.” Monopolist – “Throw him a promise!”

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1883-01-31

The great municipal “freak” – the New York tax-payer

The great municipal “freak” – the New York tax-payer

Puck, as a barker at a sideshow, presents as a “freak” the New York City tax payer. Puck points to a sign on the wall that states “Here you are now! The New York Tax-Payer!! The Greatest Curiosity ever on Exhibition! He pays $36 Per Capita. For the Privilege of Living in the Dirtiest and Worst-Governed City in the World!” Tax payers from Brooklyn at “$10.88 per capita, Berlin $7.35 per capita, Paris $5.40 per capita, [and] London $7.40 per capita” view the exhibit. Caption: He excites the wonder and amusement of the civilized world – including Brooklyn.

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1886-01-06

Christmas at Washington

Christmas at Washington

Several members of Congress stand around a large Christmas tree labeled “Tax Surplus” decorated with money bags labeled “Surplus.” The legislators carry bags in which to place the bags of surplus they pluck from the tree. Among those identified are Charles W. Jones holding a bag labeled “Naval,” William E. Chandler holding a bag labeled “Subsidies for a Merchant Steam Marine,” William Mahone holding a bag labeled “Public Buildings and Grounds,” John A. Logan holding a bag labeled “Appropriations” and reaching for a sack on the tree, Joseph W. Keifer lifting George M. Robeson holding a bag labeled “Partners in the New Naval Scheme,” John Roach holding a bag labeled “New Navy Scheme,” Henry L. Dawes holding a bag labeled “River & Harbor Bill,” Francis M. Cockrell holding a bag labeled “Improvement of Mississippi River,” Eugene Hale holding a bag labeled “River & Harbor Bill,” John J. Ingalls holding a bag labeled “More Pensions,” Benjamin F. Jonas holding a bag labeled “Improvement of Mississippi River,” and Elbridge G. Lapham who is speaking to two well-dressed women, one holding a bag labeled “Lobby.” Lapham is also depicted in the angel at the top of the tree holding a banner labeled “Help Yourself.” Uncle Sam dances with three men in the foreground and, on the right, a lone “Taxpayer” stands outside in the snow.

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1883-12-19

Anything for popularity!

Anything for popularity!

Print shows James G. Blaine slipping off a cask labeled “Whiskey”; under his arm is tucked a paper that states “Distribution of Surplus – Jim Blaine.” Caption: Our star diplomat par excellence, in his great whiskey-tax balancing feat.

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1883-12-12

Forgotten on purpose

Forgotten on purpose

A man labeled “Tax-payer” has fallen on steps labeled “Congress.” He has a large boulder labeled “War Taxes on Iron on Sugar on Cloth Salt Leather [and] Linens” strapped to his back. On the steps is a small stone labeled “Tax Taken Off Patent Medicines, Perfumery, etc.” In the room at the top of the steps, many hands dip into a bowl of coins labeled “River & Harbor Bill.” Caption: “He asked for bread, and they gave him a stone!”

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1882-08-09

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to William Loeb

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to William Loeb

If there is a large crowd, Theodore Roosevelt wants to limit disappointment and give everyone a chance to see him. Roosevelt has sent several items to William Loeb and requests that he pay the duty for them from the Douglas Robinson account.

Collection

Harvard College Library

Creation Date

1910-04-21