Samuel W. Pennypacker, governor of Pennsylvania, wearing a fools’ cap, tries to block the light of “Publicity” with a sheet of paper labeled “Pennsylvania Gag Law.” The light from a lantern held by a hand labeled “Press” is exposing Matthew S. Quay, a senator from Pennsylvania.
comments and context
Comments and Context
One of the great episodes in the history of political cartooning in America occurred in 1903, and is largely forgotten today… but might repeat itself if circumstances align. Governor Samuel Pennypacker of Pennsylvania had been annoyed by gibes from two former New York City cartoonists in Philadelphia, Charles Nelan and Walt McDougall, then of the Philadelphia North American newspaper. The paper was Republican — later, in 1912, one of the most prominent papers to support Theodore Roosevelt in Republican primaries and thereafter — but recognized the state’s Republican political boss, Senator Matthew Stanley Quay, and his cousin the governor, as corrupt. It was their cartoons of Pennypacker as a parrot, repeating the words of Quay, that were especially nettling.
The Salus-Grady Act, making editors as well as cartoonists liable for supposedly defamatory drawings, actually was passed into law, although never enforced. It banned “any cartoon or caricature or picture portraying, describing or representing any person, either by distortion, innuendo or otherwise, in the form or likeness of beast, bird, fish, insect, or other unhuman [sic] animal, thereby tending to expose such person to public hatred, contempt, or ridicule.”