Your TR Source

Immigrants

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Robert Haven Schauffler

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Robert Haven Schauffler

Theodore Roosevelt looks forward to reading Robert Haven Schauffler’s article and mentions that Edith Kermit Carow Roosevelt wants to see Schauffler the next time he is in New York. Roosevelt discusses the mix of races in the United States and agreed with Schauffler’s opinions, but he suggests that, next time, he mention who the foreigners were. Roosevelt suggests that Jewish children are brighter than American children and Irish children come afterwards, but for the police department, the opposite is true. Roosevelt recommended that they avoid dogmatism and complete generalization, though.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1912-02-02

Forgotten fragments (#11): A parable of the blindness of conviction

Forgotten fragments (#11): A parable of the blindness of conviction

Tweed Roosevelt describes two failed attempts by Scottish settlers to establish a colony on the isthmus of Panama. Roosevelt examines the conditions in seventeenth-century Scotland, notably a prolonged drop in temperatures or “the Little Ice Age,” that prompted the exodus, and he highlights how the lack of proper planning, poor leadership, and the harsh conditions doomed both expeditions. Roosevelt highlights one of the survivors of the second attempt, Archibald Stobo, who settled in Charleston, South Carolina, rather than return to Scotland. Stobo’s daughter would marry into the Bulloch family and her lineage can be traced to Martha Bulloch Roosevelt, Theodore Roosevelt’s mother. 

 

Two photographs and two illustrations appear in the article.

Reviews

Reviews

Eleven topics vie for attention in the “Reviews” section, including six book review essays, three of which are written by John A. Gable. Harry N. Lembeck revisits Jacob A. Riis’s 1904 biography Theodore Roosevelt the Citizen and finds it especially valuable for learning about Theodore Roosevelt’s tenure as Police Commissioner of New York City. Jeremy M. Murphy says that Eric Rauchway’s Murdering McKinley goes against the prevailing trend that sees Roosevelt’s progressivism as genuine, and he disputes Rauchway’s conclusions about the fate of the Socialist Party in the United States. Gable notes that James Chace’s 1912 makes no use of primary sources, but he recommends it “as a good place to start on the election of 1912.”

In his review of Daniel J. Philippon’s Conserving Words, Edward Renehan focuses on Roosevelt, his writings about hunting and ranching in Dakota, and his founding of the Boone & Crockett Club. Gable notes that John P. Avlon identifies Roosevelt as a model centrist in his Independent Nation, and he says that Richard D. White’s Roosevelt the Reformer provides a biography of Roosevelt during his years as a Civil Service Commissioner. The section also has an excerpt from the writings of Douglas Brinkley, notes the passing of Edward Wagenknecht, author of The Seven Worlds of Theodore Roosevelt, and announces that the 2004 meeting of the Theodore Roosevelt Association (TRA) will be held in Portland, Oregon. An article on the vice presidential candidates in the election of 1904 and two letters to the TRA praising its journal close out the section.

Photographs of Roosevelt and Avlon appear in the section along with a text box with a quote from Roosevelt about the 1904 campaign.

“My Blood is Half Southern”

“My Blood is Half Southern”

In three speeches on October 20, 1905, President Theodore Roosevelt addresses a variety of topics in front of crowds in Roswell and Atlanta, Georgia. Roosevelt notes the courage and devotion to duty of soldiers on both sides of the Civil War, and he states that he can take pride in his Southern heritage. Roosevelt asserts that large corporations should be regulated by the federal government and that political corruption should be identified and eliminated. He notes that the problem of Chinese immigration needs to be addressed by Congress, and he comments on the importance of cotton to the Southern economy. Roosevelt also states that he enjoys the stories of Georgia’s Joel Chandler Harris precisely because they have moral themes that imbue him “with the purpose of being a better man.” John A. Gable provides an introduction to the speeches.

Six photographs of Bulloch Hall in Roswell, Georgia, accompany the text as does a photograph of nearby Barrington Hall. A text box lists the members of the executive committee of the Theodore Roosevelt Association.

Collection

Theodore Roosevelt Association Journal

Naturalization

Naturalization

A compilation of standards and legislative decisions that factor into the process of naturalization for non-citizens of the United States. The document also includes questions asked to naturalization applicants with notable incorrect answers. 

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1911-05-19

Where would we be?

Where would we be?

Henry Cabot Lodge, labeled “A.D. 1620,” cowers before a Native who is about to hit him with a club around which a paper is wrapped that states “An Act to Prevent the Country from being Overrun by Foreigners.”

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1898-03-30

Uncle Sam’s lodging-house

Uncle Sam’s lodging-house

Print shows an Irishman confronting Uncle Sam in a boarding house filled with laborers, immigrants from several countries who are attempting to sleep. The “Frenchman, Japanese, Negro, Russian, Italian,” and “German” sleep peacefully. The “Irishman” kicks up a row. He has thrown such bricks as “The Chinese must go,” “Recall Lowell,” and “Irish independence” at Uncle Sam and the female figure of liberty standing on the left. He disturbs a “Chinese” man and an “Englishman,” who are in the berths next to him. Caption: Uncle Sam – “Look here, you, everybody else is quiet and peaceable, and you’re all the time a-kicking up a row!”

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1882-06-07

The false “friend of the workingman”

The false “friend of the workingman”

James G. Blaine stands before starving miners outside the entrance to the “Hocking Valley Mines.” He is holding a paper that states “Blaine’s $25,000 share in ‘Hocking Valley’ Ohio,” and on the ground behind him is a paper that states “I have never ‘owned a share of stock in any coal, iron or land company in the state of Ohio’ J. G. Blaine.” In the background, on the left, is a large house with banner that states “J. G. Blaine’s Washington House cost $150,000,” and at center a band of “Italian Cheap Labor” miners are coming up the road. Caption: Hungry Miner – “You call yourself our friend! Your ask for our votes! Why, you are the ally of the monopolists who starved us out in Hocking Valley, and imported cheap Italian laborers to take our places!”

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Creation Date

1884-10-15

County problems

County problems

Theodore Roosevelt describes the problems he observes in a county that has absorbed successive waves of immigrants. Some of the newcomers to the county are wealthy, and for the most part, they do not dwell there and contribute to community life. The people who do have roots in the county are made up of a mix of “old native stock” and new immigrants, and each group has its own problems. Among the old families, the philosophy of individualism, with no responsibility owed to others, has degraded the sense of community. Although material prosperity has grown, many families have regressed. Rather than stewarding their good fortune wisely, they frittered it away in get-rich-quick schemes or simply stopped working. In addition to being seduced by wealth, many of them lost church connections. This loss leads to a tendency “to let the home run down and to be shiftless in labor.”

The immigrants offer a different set of problems. They value hard work, but they prize self-reliance so highly as to lack a sense of duty to the community. The Germans and the Irish were able to assimilate into the community over time, but the recent immigrants, predominantly Poles and Italians, find assimilation more difficult. The public school is the only “Americanizing institution” they encounter, and while the school does admirable work, other agencies must reinforce and supplement the schools’ work. The church is among those agencies, along with guilds and societies and clubs for men and women.

Finally, Roosevelt discusses the need to provide healthy entertainment, including hard sport. The YMCA and the Boy Scouts are commended for their contributions to the growth of young men. These organizations may be key to stemming the tide of migration from the rural areas into the cities.

This article was published in Ladies Home Journal in October 1917.

How John may dodge the exclusion act

How John may dodge the exclusion act

Uncle Sam’s boot kicks a Chinese immigrant off a dock as part of an anti-Chinese immigration campaign. Vignettes show how the Chinese can possibly emigrate to the United States, by coming as “a cup-challenger” in yacht races, “as an industrious anarchist,” or “disguised as an humble Irishman,” or “as an English wife-hunter” with “pedigree” in his pocket, or wielding knife and handgun, as a mean-looking “peaceful, law-abiding Sicilian.”

Comments and Context

A 1905 Puck cartoon by J. S. Pughe might seem on the surface merely to be a humorous, if stereotype-laden, treatment of immigration issues of the day, particularly the difficulty of Chinese immigration leading to comic subterfuge. It would be that; but there were deeper, longer-lasting, and core consequential aspects to the problem. A modern version might have immigrants wishing to enter the United States to pose as Mexicans, whose ease of border crossings has been legendary; that would be upside-down as a cartoon concept, but relates to the larger issue.

Chinese immigration to the Western half of the United States became an issue after the Civil War, when laborers were imported to help build the railroads. This only became an issue as the railroads neared completion; when other recent immigrants (European, mostly Irish) felt their jobs threatened and nativist sentiments were inflamed. Periodic breakouts of bubonic plagues in California’s Chinatowns upset older resident groups.

Liberty?

Liberty?

A caricature of the Statue of Liberty replaces Liberty with a labor union “Walking Delegate.” His torch is labeled “Lawlessness” and he holds a tablet labeled “Tyranny.” At the base are crowds of immigrants disembarking from boats, as other boats stream across the sea from a location marked with a sign that states “To the Land of the Free.”

Comments and Context

A generation earlier, the concept of this cartoonist might have featured only a different label or two. The caricature of the Statue of Liberty might have represented an urban political boss and municipal corruption. Instead, here, the arriving immigrants, depicted in their various native outfits, are confounded by the tyranny of the crooked labor boss, the “Walking Delegate” union organizer, and advocate of violence. At this point in time, this is how many American citizens, not only immigrants, saw a large part of the labor movement.

Collection

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs

Letter from Secretary of Theodore Roosevelt to Frank L. Frugone

Letter from Secretary of Theodore Roosevelt to Frank L. Frugone

In regards to Frank L. Frugone’s letter about the questioning of immigrants, the secretary to Theodore Roosevelt clarifies that it was a judge, not Roosevelt himself who asked the questions. The questions about immigrants’ membership to secret societies, like the Comorra Mafia-connected Black Hand, was necessary and proper. Frugone was editor of numerous Italian-language newspapers for immigrants throughout his career.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1911-05-23

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to George Van Horn Moseley

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to George Van Horn Moseley

Theodore Roosevelt is interested in the suggestions Captain Moseley has on training U.S. military forces. Roosevelt does not agree with Moseley’s two types of training, one for those with a college education and one for those without, as he would wish his own sons to “serve with the colors.” Roosevelt does, however, agree about the immigrants and favors the term “universal training” over “conscription.”

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1915-11-17

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Frank P. Sargent

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Frank P. Sargent

President Roosevelt asks Commissioner General of Immigration Sargent to go to Honolulu to supervise the landing of Southern European immigrants. Roosevelt believes this is one of the most important matters to happen since the Hawaiian islands became a colony of the United States and would like his personal supervision.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1906-11-08

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Finley Peter Dunne

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Finley Peter Dunne

President Roosevelt agrees with Finley Peter Dunne about protesting against the “Anglo-Saxon alliance” theory because he believes Americans are “a new race, composed of many Old-World stocks.” While the president is not against friendliness to the English government, he is not going to ignore other European governments. Roosevelt declares himself a “strong home-ruler” and gives examples of a number of individuals who have hated their country of origin, noting it is impossible for him to champion every hatred. The president expresses his gratitude for the support he has received from young men, “Catholic by faith and of Irish descent,” and discusses a number of Irish and Catholic individuals he has put in government positions.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1904-12-03