A sketch after Trumbull’s painting “The Declaration of Independence” shows John Adams, Roger Sherman, Robert R. Livingston, Thomas Jefferson, and Charles Thomson, standing around a table where John Hancock is sitting, as a businessman labeled “Spirit of 1908” rushes in from the left. Caption: Where would we be now if modern counsel had prevailed in ’76?
Comments and Context
The objections of “big business” and “robber barons” to most proposed reforms and gradual cleansing of the American business economy was long-standing. It was predictable, almost continuous from every perspective of argumentation — literally reactionary.
Yet the context of this cartoon by S.D. Ehrhart likely was not the economy in general, or the prerogatives of major entrepreneurs in general, but the response to the Wall Street Panic of the previous October. Few corporate titans blamed their own activities or back-room chicanery. It was easy to advocate for the status quo — “standing pat” as to policies — and blame the Panic on the number of Muckrakers’ exposures, the wave of new laws and regulations, and the “agitation” generated by the incessant criticisms of President Roosevelt.