Your TR Source

Battleships--Design and construction

Bow view of the powerful U.S. battleship “Indiana”

Bow view of the powerful U.S. battleship “Indiana”

Colored stereograph of the bow of the USS Indiana. Text on the reverse of the stereograph discusses the considerations that must be made when constructing a battleship for “effective aggressive and defensive warfare,” such as guns and armor, coal intake, and missile defense.

Comments and Context

As printed on the reverse of the stereograph, “A battleship is a wonder of design and construction. Every known device is employed, every branch of human knowledge and skill is laid under contribution to achieve perfection in a thousand details. A battleship must be prepared for effective aggressive and defensive warfare, which means that it must carry the most powerful guns and ammunition known, must have good speed, must be able to travel a considerable distance without recoaling, and, above all, must be protected from serious damage by the enemy’s missiles. The task of those who plan a new battleship is, therefore, a very complicated and difficult one. The enormous weight of the armor, of the guns and the coal that must be carried, cause a large displacement, which again necessitates powerful engines to drive the ship through the water, and the running of the engines requires vast quantities of coal. Add to this the necessity of comfortable quarters for the officers and men, large rooms for storing provisions and the paramount requirement of ample room for handling the guns, and you have an idea how much ingenuity it takes to plan and build one of these floating fortresses.”

Collection

Duane G. Jundt Theodore Roosevelt Collection

Armor trust defeats rivals

Armor trust defeats rivals

Secretary of the Navy Bonaparte has directed that the contract to provide armor plate for two newly constructed battleships be split between the Midvale Company and the “so-called trust companies, namely, the Carnegie and the Bethlehem Companies.” Bonaparte issued a statement clarifying how he came to this decision, specifying that legislation obliges him to choose the cheapest bidders, and that he believes the armor will be most rapidly procured by splitting the contract three ways among the companies.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1906-07-11

Memorandum by William Sowden Sims

Memorandum by William Sowden Sims

In a memorandum, Commander Sims addresses the need to appoint a new Engineer-in-Chief for the Navy. The Board on Construction’s sudden decision in 1904 to design smaller battleships was due to Senator Eugene Hale’s influence with the Engineer-in-Chief and the Board. Hale has a history of influencing the Navy, and Sims recommends appointing a new Engineer-in-Chief who is not controlled by Hale.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1908-06-01

Report on water line belts

Report on water line belts

Despite Admiral Robley D. Evans’s conclusion that water line belts are too high, the real vulnerability on battleships is that they do not have enough armored protection at and above the water line. Further, ships are not carrying the draft levels recommended but are exceeding them.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1908-04-14

Hearings before the Committee on Naval Affairs, United States Senate, on the bill (S.3335) to increase the efficiency of the personnel of the Navy and Marine Corps of the United States

Hearings before the Committee on Naval Affairs, United States Senate, on the bill (S.3335) to increase the efficiency of the personnel of the Navy and Marine Corps of the United States

The Senate Committee on Naval Affairs interviews a number of naval officers on some alleged defects in the construction of several battleships now being built. Chief among these concerns are the questions of the placement of the armor belt, the positions of the guns, and the design of the hoists to provide the turrets with ammunition.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1908-03-21

Additional statement by Commander A. L. Key, U.S. Navy, to the chairman and members of the Senate Naval Committee

Additional statement by Commander A. L. Key, U.S. Navy, to the chairman and members of the Senate Naval Committee

Commander Key responds to reports by Rear Admiral George Albert Converse and Chief Constructor of the Navy W. L. Capps about the construction of American battleships compared to Japanese and British battleships. Key points out errors and inconsistencies in the reports, and argues that the water line armor belts on American battleships are incorrectly placed and not thick enough. He believes the United States needs to be building ships based on the most up-to-date knowledge about battleship construction and design. He also takes issue with the lack of battle tactics practice in the Atlantic Fleet’s maneuvers.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1908-03-21

Synopsis of enclosed letters on the question of the distribution of water line belt armor on battleships in the United States Navy

Synopsis of enclosed letters on the question of the distribution of water line belt armor on battleships in the United States Navy

Summary of thirteen letters addressing the question of the distribution of water line belt armor on battleships in the United States Navy. Summarized letters include discussions between admirals, government reports, letters from the Bureau of Construction, and information from international sources.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1908-03-03

Special report on alleged battleship defects

Special report on alleged battleship defects

Rear Admiral Converse issues a special report defending a previous report he had written about the construction of battleships against recent criticisms. Converse maintains that recent reports criticizing his report on the construction of gun turrets, and drafts of battleships misrepresent the actual situation, and are fundamentally flawed. Accompanying his report are several exhibits highlighting the portions of the criticism that Converse specifically rebuts.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1908-03-03

Memorandum concerning the Brazilian dreadnoughts now building in England

Memorandum concerning the Brazilian dreadnoughts now building in England

A memorandum containing summary of Commander Simon P. Fullinwider’s letter from December 6, 1907, which criticizes Brazil’s construction of large and expensive dreadnoughts and says they may be Japan’s project. He recommends the United States ready their fleet accordingly and dismiss Japanese men aboard the ships, who he thinks could be spies. Commander Sims writes that the officers will learn more while in Rio, and he shares Fullinwider’s concerns about “foreign servants” and enlisted men sharing confidential information.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1907-12-19

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to John Davis Long

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to John Davis Long

Assistant Secretary of the Navy Roosevelt urges Secretary Long to advise President McKinley not to conduct a joint investigation with Spain into the sinking of the USS Maine. Roosevelt believes that, in spite of opposition, Long should recommend that Congress authorize the building of as many as four battleships.

Collection

Massachusetts Historical Society

Creation Date

1898-02-19

Memorandum expressing concerns about the U.S. Navy

Memorandum expressing concerns about the U.S. Navy

For the U.S. Navy to fulfill its mission, it must be able to meet its enemies on equal terms. This principle has not been maintained in the building of recent battleships and other vessels. If the ships are adequate, sometimes the gunnery is not. Not enough people have been allowed to have input on the design. Opportunity for promotion for younger sailors is also a concern. There should be an easier track to promotion so there are younger experienced officers in the event of war. The memorandum includes statistics on the age of U.S. Navy officers compared with those of England, Germany, Russia, and Japan.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1904-10-12

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Albert L. Key

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Albert L. Key

President Roosevelt is confused and angered by the message Commander Key is trying to send about his opinion on the administration of the Navy, and cautions Key against disobeying his order. He takes exception with Key’s previous claim that Roosevelt has been misinformed regarding the Newport conference, and points out that the opinions of those Key identifies with are often proven to be wrong. Roosevelt is not yet certain whether there should be a court-martial placed on Key, but he claims it may be necessary to reduce any harm he may cause the Navy. Roosevelt also discusses the construction of a new type of naval ship he has been overseeing.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1909-01-08

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Truman Handy Newberry

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Truman Handy Newberry

President Roosevelt has had his attention called to the annual report of Rear Admiral W. L. Capps, Constructor of the Navy, in which Capps made comments concerning criticisms by Commander Albert L. Key about the design of the North Dakota. Roosevelt tells Secretary of the Navy Newberry that this is the “most flagrant possible violation of my directions as to avoiding public recrimination between officers,” and says that if Capps has any explanation for this, he would like to hear it.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1908-12-29

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Truman Handy Newberry

Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to Truman Handy Newberry

President Roosevelt tells Acting Secretary of the Navy Newberry that he is “puzzled what to do” about the papers he submitted. In particular, he takes issue with a statement from Professor Philip R. Alger which says that going to a larger caliber of weapon now would acknowledge that the Navy’s former action was an error. This makes Roosevelt distrust both Alger’s judgment and that of Rear Admiral Newton E. Mason. Roosevelt is against the Navy’s hesitancy to refuse new suggestions, and says that he wants the United States to lead other nations in new developments.

Collection

Library of Congress Manuscript Division

Creation Date

1908-11-25